Compare Engagement Rings

From quality and product selection to shipping & returns and help & support, we research everything you need to compare engagement rings and make a decision. Learn how our editors compare the different factors of engagement rings below.
Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn more.
Select 2 engagement rings companies to compare

How we Compare Engagement Rings

Quality - 25%
Product Selection - 20%
Services Offered - 15%
Warranties - 15%
Shipping & Returns - 15%
Help & Support - 10%


When choosing the perfect engagement ring, the first thing you must consider is the quality of the diamonds, gemstones, and metals used in making the ring you’ve chosen. Taking into account the 4 C’s – color, cut, clarity, and carat weight – is essential when selecting a diamond engagement ring. Engagement rings must also be accompanied by a certification of grading report from known laboratories to ensure buyers that the product is conflict-free and has good value.

  • AGS – American Gem Society Laboratories
  • GIA – Gemological Institute of America

Engagement Rings with the Best Quality:

Product Selection

The best store for an engagement ring must be able to offer a wide collection of pre-set rings in different styles and settings. Jewellery retailers should also cater to the different needs and tastes of their customers. The wider a selection a jewellery store has, the more options can be offered to their buyers.

Engagement Rings with the Best Product Selection:

RitaniJames AllenJaredJewelry.comZalesKay JewelersAmazonJewelry WarehouseSuper JewelersAllurez
Three Stone
Blue Topaz

Services Offered

You must consider the different services provided by the jewellery store while shopping and after purchasing an engagement ring. Jewellery stores must also have a “Create Your Own Ring” service that will allow you to build or submit a unique design for your desired engagement ring. Other services that you must look for in a jewellery store are their financing programs and diamond certifications.

Engagement Rings with the Best Services Offered:

James AllenJaredJewelry.comZalesKay JewelersAmazonJewelry WarehouseSuper JewelersAllurez
Design Your Own
Gift Wrapping
Gift Cards
Diamond Certification
Gold Exchange


It is essential that a jewellery store accompanies their products with lifetime warranties that are free of charge. Some of these warranties are lifetime cleaning and inspection, diamond upgrade, and repairs. This will ensure you of the quality of the product you’ve purchased from the jewellery store.

Engagement Rings with the Best Warranties:

Shipping and Returns

Jewellery stores must provide a hassle-free returns and insured shipping methods. Some jewellery retailers offer free insured shipping without minimum purchase required. Other stores require their customer’s signature upon delivery for protection of their order.

Engagement Rings with the Best Shipping and Returns:

RitaniJames AllenJaredJewelry.comZalesKay JewelersAmazonJewelry WarehouseSuper JewelersAllurez
Money Back Guarantee
Free Shipping
Lifetime Warranty
Return Period30-Days30-Days30-Days30-Days60-Days60-Days30-Days30-Days60-Days30-Days
Signature Required
Next Day Shipping
Insured Shipping

Help and Support

A timely response and friendly approach is a big factor for customers when they are choosing to patronize a certain jewellery store. It is also important that an in-store expert must address every possible concern and assist customers in finding the perfect engagement ring in accordance with their preference.

Engagement Rings with the Best Help and Support:

Full Engagement Rings Comparison

QualityProduct SelectionServices OfferedWarrantiesShipping and ReturnsHelp and Support
Ritani Engagement Rings9.
James Allen Engagement Rings10.
Jared Engagement Rings9. Engagement Rings10.08.08.610.08.79.0
Zales Engagement Rings9.
Kay Jewelers Engagement Rings9.
Amazon Engagement Rings10.
Jewelry Warehouse Engagement Rings9.
Super Jewelers Engagement Rings9.
Allurez Engagement Rings8.
Tiffany & Co. Engagement Rings10.
Cartier Engagement Rings9.
De Beers Engagement Rings8.
JCPenny Engagement Rings7.
Blue Nile Engagement Rings6.
Helzberg Diamonds Engagement Rings6.
Robbins Brothers Engagement Rings6.
Brilliant Earth Engagement Rings6.
Select 2 engagement rings companies to compare

Latest Reviews

Kizzy Mckinzy
Poor people love beautiful things as well

Reviews help other customers make decisions. Share your experience with Engagement Rings