Select My Policy Renters Insurance Review

Rating: 7 / 10 (Very good)
Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from this partner. 
Learn more.
Select My Policy is a completely free insurance market that allows consumers to search for auto, life, health, home, and renters insurance policies. By filling out their secure online quote tool, consumers are able to receive and compare quotes from multiple insurance companies nationwide.

How is Select My Policy rated?


Financial Strength
Pricing & Discounts
Customer Experience

Overall Rating: 7 / 10 (Very good)

Select My Policy is a renters, auto, home, life, and health insurance marketplace which connects consumers to quotes from multiple different insurers, allowing them to compare competing rates and plans easily and quickly, after filling out some simple data.

Select My Policy Coverage

Coverage - 8 / 10

Since Select My Policy operates as a marketplace for renters insurance companies within their network, each insurer will have different coverage options. Customers are well advised to carefully compare each company's plans, considering that most industry leaders offer a basic suite of three coverages: personal property, liability, and loss of use or additional living expenses. Also bear in mind whether you'd prefer valuation of your property to be for actual cash value or for replacement costs.
Basic Coverage
Personal Property
Personal Liability
Loss of Use / Additional Living Expenses

Pricing & Discounts

Pricing & Discounts - 7 / 10

Since Select My Policy doesn't offer insurance products in and of themselves, but rather connects customers with well-respected renters insurance providers from their vetted network, pricing and discounts are impossible to ascertain accurately. However, bear in mind that companies commonly offer discounts for security systems, fire protection, sprinklers, multi-policy options, and customers with claims-free histories.
Property-Level Discounts
Burglary Protected
Fire Protection
Sprinkler System

Customer Experience

Customer Experience - 6 / 10

Since doesn't underwrite renters insurance policies itself, consumers should verify the ratings held by the individual companies they are matched with through's quote service. Independent review websites such as the Better Business Bureau and TrustPilot can be good starting-off points in this research.

Financial Strength Ratings

Financial Strength - 6 / 10

Select My Policy offers the advantage of putting consumers in touch with a multitude of different companies that offer renters insurance, from their network of partners. We highly recommend that prospective customers do their homework on the selection of insurers they're matched with, checking their financial ratings with organizations such as Standard & Poor's and Moody's. It's essential to understand an insurer's financial strength, as this essentially determines their ability to meet claims efficiently.
Standard & Poor's Financial Rating
Moody's Financial Rating
AM Best Financial Rating
Company Type
*The above information reflects the financials strength of GEICO Corporation, an insurance company that this insurance marketplace offers policies through.

Contact & Additional Information

Homepage URL
Mailing Address
PO Box #18404, Golden, CO, 80402

Leave a comment for Select My Policy Renters Insurance
Minimum 12 words.
 No maximum length.
* What's Your Rating?
To make this comment as helpful as possible for our community, please provide at least 2 sentences.

Our Partner
7.0 / 10
  • Get free quotes from multiple renters insurance carriers
  • Wide network of renters insurance companies to choose from
  • Fast and free rate comparison platform
  • Safe and secure
  • Get savings on renters insurance premiums