Compare Bay Alarm vs. Medical Guardian Medical Alerts

What’s the difference between Bay Alarm Medical Alert and Medical Guardian Medical Alerts? See how our editors compare the two companies below.
Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn more.
Select 2 medical alerts companies to compare
vs
Bay Alarm Medical Alert
9.9 / 10 - Excellent
#1 in Medical Alerts
Our Partner
Medical Guardian
9.3 / 10 - Excellent
#2 in Medical Alerts
Our Partner
vs
Key Facts
  • Most Popular Choice - A+ Rating with BBB
  • Special pricing for AARP and USAA members
  • FREE Equipment, Activation, and Gift!
  • $25.95 per Month (billed twice a year)
  • 1,000 ft. Range. with Waterproof Pendant
  • 36-hr Battery Life.
  • Landline, Cellular, and GPS with Automatic Fall Detection
  • No Contracts or Hidden Fees!
  • USA-based and UL Certified 24/7 Monitoring Centers
  • A+ Rating with the BBB
  • 1,300 ft. button range & 72 hour Backup Battery 
  • Mobile (with GPS) & Fall Detection systems available
  • UL and CSAA Five Diamond Certified Monitoring Centers
  • No long-term Contracts
  • FREE Equipment, Activation, and Shipping!
  • Price Lock Guarantee & Lifetime Warranty on Equipment
ConsumersAdvocate.org Ratings
9.9 / 10 - Excellent
10/10
Equipment & Features
10/10
Coverage
10/10
Maintenance & Repairs
10/10
Monitoring Services
10/10
Service Agreements
9/10
Cost
9/10
Reviews
9.3 / 10 - Excellent
10/10
Equipment & Features
10/10
Coverage
9/10
Maintenance & Repairs
10/10
Monitoring Services
8/10
Service Agreements
8/10
Cost
9/10
Reviews
Customer Reviews
 (723)
8.8 / 10 - Excellent
81%
5 stars
9%
4 stars
2%
3 stars
2%
2 stars
5%
1 stars
 (416)
8.6 / 10 - Excellent
72%
5 stars
16%
4 stars
5%
3 stars
2%
2 stars
4%
1 stars
Final Verdict

Bay Alarm Medical Alert has a higher overall rating than Medical Guardian Medical Alerts. Bay Alarm scores better than Medical Guardian across: Maintenance & Repairs, Service Agreements, and Cost. Both companies score similarly on Equipment & Features, Coverage, Monitoring Services, and Reviews.

Latest Reviews

CR
Radford, Virginia
Bay Alarm Medical Alert review
3/22/2017
My 91-year-old mom fell at five in the morning and broke her wrist. Fortunately, she was wearing her alarm and pushed the button. Bay Alarm Medical phoned me. I went to her house to check on her, and when I called 911, I was told they were already on the way. They had all the information I had submitted to Bay Alarm Medical, so they knew how to get to her house and which one it was. (Not as easy as it sounds.) While one hopes no one will ever fall, I have to say that everything went exactly as it was supposed to. Bay Alarm Medical was a step ahead of me the whole way. Thank you, Bay Alarm Medical! I did a lot of research before deciding on a medical alert company, and Bay Alarm Medical had raves. I now know why.

F
[email protected]
,
Medical Guardian Medical Alerts review
3/3/2017
I would've awarded 5 stars if the charging base were a bit less particular about how the mobile device is placed in it. Charging hasn't always succeeded.

T
Tim
Medical Guardian Medical Alerts review
2/24/2017
The initial signup process was excellent and all of the components were received as promised. The setup process as easy to do, however, my unsuspecting mother was talked in to a maintenance plan that was not discussed with me during the initial signup process.

D
Desiree
Santa Clara, California
Bay Alarm Medical Alert review
1/27/2017
Ordered this for my mom who is 72 and couldn't be more happy with the service. She's accidentally hit the alert buttons and within seconds she's received phone calls from Bay Alarm, the fire department and/or police. We know that it works!! Thanks Bay Alarm, highly recommend!

Bay Shore, New York
Bay Alarm Medical Alert review
3/17/2016
I have just recently submitted a review

R
Randi G
Marlboro, New Jersey
Medical Guardian Medical Alerts review
3/1/2016
I called for some information for my mom. I was not intending to sign up. Robin was so good at informing me about all the services. I ended up paying for a full year and insurance by the time we hung up. He took his time and never rushed me. He answered all my questions no matter how many times I asked the same question. He is excellent at his job. I never looked anywhere else.

T
Tony E
Chicago, Illinois
Bay Alarm Medical Alert review
9/28/2015
Great system

J
JAMES b
Dallas, Georgia
Medical Guardian Medical Alerts review
3/13/2015
they don't want a review tried to sent two bad one hit sumit button it did not send either one.don;t do bus.with them